The following compilation was drawn from the Institute of Paper Chemistry's Bibliographic Series No. 213, "Permanence," by Jerry Byrne and Jack Weiner (1964). The "Reference Number" is that of the bibliography entry. Not every entry that mentioned acid is included, because trivial or derivative works are excluded. "Factors Identified" are the author's comments an the role of acidity in deterioration of paper, as given in the abstract.
Ref. # | Date | Author &/or lab | Factors Identified |
93 | 1910 | Edlund | Author asks whether large quantities of acid salts like alum could injure durability of paper. |
69 | 1926 | Dillont | "Free acidity" is one of many factors identified. |
155 | 1928 | Hoffman | "Internal" acidity; minimum pH should be 4.7. |
67 | 1929 | Bur. Stds. | Acidity of paper accelerates deterioration. |
156 | 1930 | Hoffman & Olsen | Minimum pH should be 4.8 or 5.0. |
14 | 1930 | Baker | Acidic and oxidizing degradation. |
39 | 1931 | Bur. Stds. | Acidity is closely related to change in alpha-cellulose content & loss of strength after aging. |
211 | 1931 | Korn | pH value is important to durability. |
267 | 1932 | Minor | Acidity of degraded paper bears no relation to its loss of folding strength. |
198 | 1932 | Klemm | Complete absence of acidity is an important requirement. |
323 | 1933 | Rasch/Bur. Stds | For stability, careful control of Bur. Stds. acidity is necessary. |
266 | 1934 | Minor | Acidity is 1 of 6 factors to be manufactured for permanent/durable paper. |
378 | 1935 | Shaw/NBS | pH 5.0 is optimal for stability. Higher acidity (i.e., lower pH) deteriorates paper. |
57 | 1935 | Clark | Acidity is 1 of 4 or more factors. |
28 | 1935 | Berndt | Reviews effect of pH on strength & permanence of paper. |
406 | 1936 | Strachen | For permanence, use a pH of 6-7; omit alum & rosin. |
166 | 1936 | Jarrell/Dept. Agric. | Most acidic papers deteriorate most rapidly |
125 | 1939 | Hanson | Good sheets in book showed high pH. |
37 | 1940 | Brecht & Michaelis | pH not correlated with heat stability at 120°C for 24 hours. |
40 | 1948 | Buyn | Summarizes NBS work, explains it, 6 variables including pH. |
172 | 1951 | Kantrowitz | Recommends pH of 5.0 or higher. |
42 | 1951 | Buyn | Recommends only volatile organic acids be used. |
227 | 1952 | Langwell | Sufficiently strong acid destroys even rag paper; acid form hydro cellulose, which damages paper. |
334 | 1952 | Reid | pH should be higher than 5.0 for white paper and 4.7 for colored paper (text of abstract ambiguous). |
279 | 1953 | Mohrberg | pH should be between 4.5 and 8.0. |
251 | 1954 | Mackenzie | Any paper with a high residual acidity will yellow and embrittle with age. |
19 | 1959 | Barrow | The low permanence of modern book paper is caused mainly by its acidity. |
49 | 1959 | Chene | Permanence can be increased by substituting sodium aluminate for half the alum, thus increasing pH to 6.0. |
157 | 1959 | Angew. Chem. | Acidity from chlorine & bisulfite residues reduce life expectancy, so neutralize them with CaCO3. |
51 | 1959 | Church | Acidity is a major cause of book deterioration. |
360 | 1960 | Scott | Long-life paper should have a pH 5-6. |