Re: ociclean

[Jerry Shiner <keepsafe@xxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Joan,

Are you concerned about museum artifacts, or is this about the old 
tablecloth or antique dress that was rescued from a yard sale?

Perhaps this product is the combination of enzymes and something like 
sodium percarbonate (which I understand is more effective than sodium 
perborate). Perhaps the cleaning procedures are more effective (a longer 
soaking?, warmer water?). Perhaps it is only a little better than a 
commercial detergent. By definition, if it was the subject of an 
infomercial, it had to be miraculous! My guess is that it's a clever 
combination of common ingredients, very cleverly sold.

The question is one of cost vs benefit. If it works, and revives an 
otherwise lost garment, why not use it? The equation would be very 
different if you were treating the Shroud of Turin (a popular 14'th century 
tourist attraction now turned into a papal infomercial, to be sure). I 
think a professional conservator would have very little freedom to say 
anything in the abstract. Unless they have solid data about the chemicals 
involved, tests done, and long-term effects, how could they respond?  (I 
however, am prone to writing this kind of note.) Good luck!

Jerry Shiner
Forever Yours Bridal Gown Preservation
www.gowncare.com  800 683-4696





Joan Kiplinger wrote:
>      Need some pro opinions. A new book out on rescuing vintage textiles
> recommends using OxiClean to remove stains and brighten. This product is
> an enzyme/oxygen cleaner with no toxic chemcials, cleaning solvents or
> harmful abrasives and can only be used on cotton or linen. It apparently
> steps in if sodium perborate can't do the job. Has anyone heard of using
> this cleaner on on old fabric and is it safe? I would appear hesitant
> using on delicate heirlooms after watching OxiClean informercial. But
> what about old barkcloth drapes, table cloths, etc. where appearance is
> vital when in use.  Would there be any long-term effects? Author claims
> that many 1940s-50s tablecloths and curtains she thought were destined
> for the trash can were miracously restored. Any help is appreciated.

Jerry Shiner
Object & Textile Conservation Services Ltd.   O/A
Keepsafe Systems & Forever Yours Gown Bridal Preservation
Visit www.gowncare.com