[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[ARSCLIST] Fw: Cataloging. Liebesbotschaft
- To: ARSCLIST@xxxxxxxxxxxx
- Subject: [ARSCLIST] Fw: Cataloging. Liebesbotschaft
- From: Steven Smolian <smolians@xxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Wed, 27 Apr 2005 11:35:04 -0400
- Comments: To: MLA-L <MLA-L@LISTSERV.INDIANA.EDU>, ARSC List <ARSCLIST@sun8.loc.gov>, 88son78s <88sOn78s@yahoogroups.com>
- Comments: cc: "White Ted (1/03)" <twhite8@cox.net>, "Tierney, Bob" <rhtierney@comcast.net>, Stockmann_L <Stockmann_L@bls.gov>, Stewart Jim <jim.stewart@state.de.us>, Sommerfield David Frederick Sommerfield <dsom@loc.gov>, "Smith, Dorothy" <dsmith@huc.edu>, "Skene, Gordon" <obilix@aol.com>, Silverman Art <asilverman@npr.org>, Schaff Elizabeth <schaaf@PEABODY.JHU.EDU>, "Saposnik Henry (new)" <Xanajew@aol.com>, Place Jeff <jeff@folkways.si.edu>, "Nagoski, Ian" <nagoski@pigeon.berndtgroup.net>, Kelly Allan <akark@dsl.pipex.com>, "Jaro Matt (new)" <mjaro@comcast.net>, Holloway Kay <kay_holloway@hotmail.com>, Holdridge Larry <larhold@bway.net>, "Henson, Pamela" <HENSONP@OSIA.SI.EDU>, Gerber Leslie <parnassus@ulster.net>, Freed Richard <priamclay@aol.com>, Fogel Henry <henryfogel@aol.com>, "Elozua, Raymon" <raymon@elozua.com>, Detmer Roger <detrog@comcast.net>, Curran Douglas <Batwings78rpm@msn.com>, Callas Demitri <Vegascomet@aol.com>
- Message-id: <001a01c54b3e$aef87060$0100a8c0@smoliano2w7958>
- Reply-to: Association for Recorded Sound Discussion List <ARSCLIST@xxxxxxx>
SCHUBERT, Franz
----- Original Message -----
From: Steven Smolian
To: Smolian Steven
Sent: Tuesday, April 26, 2005 9:34 AM
Subject: Cataloging. Liebesbotschaft
This seems to work.
Note. Indents will be 2 characters. I didn't want to go through the hassle of resetting the tabs twice.
Steve
SCHUBERT, Franz
SONG CYCLES. Schwanengesang (1828), D. 957
No. 1. Liebesbotschaft (Rellstab)
Schumann, Elisabeth, sop; Gerald Moore, pf
Rec. 1937/12/04, London GrCo ORA 12333-2
HMV DA-1546 (78 10" el)
--arr. Piano (Liszt) (year?), G. 345 no. 10
Chiu, Frederic, pf
Rec. 1998/04/15-17, Nicasio, CA, Skywalker Sound. 2:46
Harmonia Mundi HMU-907,239 (CD) 1.11
SONGS: Liebesbotschaft (Rellstab) (Schwanengesang) (1828), D. 957 no. 1
Schumann, Elisabeth, sop; Gerald Moore, pf
Rec. 1937/12/04, London GrCo ORA 12333-2
HMV DA-1546 (78 10" el)
--arr. Piano (Liszt) (year?), G. 345 no. 10
Chiu, Frederic, pf
Rec. 1998/04/15-17, Nicasio, CA, Skywalker Sound. 2:46
Harmonia Mundi HMU-907,239 (CD) 1.11
Liebesbotschaft (Rellstab) (Schwanengesang) (1828), D. 957 no. 1
Schumann, Elisabeth, sop; Gerald Moore, pf
Rec. 1937/12/04, London GrCo ORA 12333-2
HMV DA-1546 (78 10" el)
--arr. Piano (Liszt) (year?), G. 345 no. 10
Chiu, Frederic, pf
Rec. 1998/04/15-17, Nicasio, CA, Skywalker Sound. 2:46
Harmonia Mundi HMU-907,239 (CD) 1.11
LISZT, Franz
TRANSCRIPTIONS for Piano
SCHUBERT, Franz
SONG CYCLES. Schwanengesang (1828), D. 957 no.1
--arr. Piano (Liszt) (year?), G. 345 no. 10
Chiu, Frederic, pf
Rec. 1998/04/15-17, Nicasio, CA, Skywalker Sound. 2:46
Harmonia Mundi HMU-907,239 (CD) 1.11
SONGS. Liebesbotschaft (Rellstab) (Schwanengesang) (1828), D. 957 no. 1
Chiu, Frederic, pf
Rec. 1998/04/15-17, Nicasio, CA, Skywalker Sound. 2:46
Harmonia Mundi HMU-907,239 (CD) 1.11
Here are five ways of listing Liszt's transcription for piano of Schubert's song, "Liebesbotschaft." The user would be offered a checkbox to determine which of these options he wants in his catalog. My personal choices would be for the second and fifth, especially since Schwanengesang is not truly a cycle but a posthumus gathering of related and unrelated unpublished works. For real cycles, I'd choose all but the third. The discographic data about the Sschumann version is made up.
My own choice of options would also put the place of recording in a hidden entry which would appear on the screen when the recording date is pointed to. Otherwise, I think it clutter.
I have no timing for the Schumann. Since 78 rpm is a nominal rather than actual speed, I'd want to be sure it was timed when playing in pitch.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
No virus found in this incoming message.
Checked by AVG Anti-Virus.
Version: 7.0.308 / Virus Database: 266.10.3 - Release Date: 4/25/2005
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Anti-Virus.
Version: 7.0.308 / Virus Database: 266.10.3 - Release Date: 4/25/2005