JAIC 2002, Volume 41, Number 3, Article 1 (pp. 203 to 223)
JAIC online
Journal of the American Institute for Conservation
JAIC 2002, Volume 41, Number 3, Article 1 (pp. 203 to 223)




1. With silhouettes bearing the name of Master Hubard, it is safest to assign them to the Hubard Gallery, as it is difficult to determine who did the actual cutting, unless the silhouette is clearly early (and then it is by Master Hubard). Hubard, born in England ca. 1807, began cutting at or around the age of 13. After creating a stir in the British Isles as a child prodigy, he came to New York in 1824 with a Mr. Smith, Hubard's sponsor who ran the “Gallery of Cuttings and Panharmonicum.” The gallery was a collection of various paper silhouettes by Hubard of people, animals, architecture, etc., and the Panharmonicum was reputed to be a musical mechanism that could play 206 instruments. In 1825 the show went to Boston; the Gallery of Cuttings and Panharmonicum was advertised regularly in Boston papers until April 1826.Hubard was probably no longer associated with Smith and the gallery after January 1828. The Gallery of Cuttings and Panharmonicum continued on. Master Hanks took over that same year, and it is likely that Hanks left by 1829. There was apparently a group of young cutters associated with the gallery, so again, a Hubard Gallery attribution is the most secure way to assign these works. Many thanks to the Laughons for telling me about cutters other than Hanks and Hubard (Laughon and Laughon 1997).The Hubard Gallery cutout silhouettes are made from matte, black-coated, white wove paper mounted to a secondary support, often a card. The gallery produced full-length and bust silhouettes. The full-length silhouettes on card often have a watercolor wash including a shadow underneath the sitter. Not infrequently, the silhouettes were modestly decorated with a gold colorant to emphasize buttons, collars, etc.

2. The stationers' and artists' material catalogs examined at the American Antiquarian Society included Cotton, Boston, 1830, 1839, and 1850; M. J. Whipple, Boston, 1851; Frost and Adams, Boston, 1875; Gibbs Brothers, Holyoke, Mass., n.d.; Wheeler and Whitney, Boston, ca. 1860; Marshall A. Lewis Co., n.d.; H. Cohen, Philadelphia, 1859; N. E. News Company, Boston, 1873; John E. Pettybone, Chicago, n.d.; Corlies Macy and Co., New York, 1874; Louis Snider, Cincinnati, n.d.; Willy Wallachs, New York, 1874. I am grateful to Judy Walsh for pointing me in the direction of the AAS.

3. For an excellent discussion of tracing machines, see Miles 1994 and Benes 1994. Benes includes a useful index of artists and dates with the names of the tracing devices they used.


Sincere thanks are due to many people who were helpful with this project: Cliff Ackley, Robert Baldwin, Georgia Barnhill, Craigen Bowen, Matt Cutler, Michele Derrick, Sarah Dove, Anne Driesse, Margaret Holben Ellis, Manfred Engeli, Theresa Fairbanks, Elizabeth Fairman, Eugene Farrell, Richard Field, Betty Fiske, Robin Jaffe Frank, Robin Hanson, Dana Hemmenway, Lisa Hodermarsky, John Krill, Helen and Nel Laughon, Carol Lebeaux, Annette Manick, Lance Mayer, Lillian Miller, Erica Mosier, Gay Myers, Richard Newman, Gisela Noack, Debbie Hess Norris, Roy Perkinson, Sue Welsh Reed, William Robinson, Edward Saywell, Gwendolyn Dubois Shaw, Helen Sheumaker, Jane Smith Stewart, Miriam Stewart, Neville Thomson, Teri Vienot, Ann Wagner, Judy Walsh, Jenna Webster, and Virginia Whelan. I am also indebted to Daniel Abramson for his patient assistance and encouragement.


Adair, W.1983. The frame in America, 1700–1900: A survey of fabrication, techniques and styles. Washington, D.C.: American Institute of Architects.

American Craftlines. 1997a. Personal communication. September 9.

American Craftlines. 1997b. Personal communication. September 11.

Barnhill, G. B.1993. Extracts from the journals of Ethan A. Greenwood: Portrait painter and museum proprietor. Proceedings of the American Antiquarian Society103:91–178.

Benes, P.1994. Machine-assisted portrait and profile imaging in New England after 1803. In Painting and portrait making in the American Northeast, ed. P.Benes. Boston: Boston University and Dublin Seminar for New England Folklife Annual Proceedings. 138–50.

Boehn, M. von.1928. Miniatures and silhouettes. London: J. M. Dent and Sons.

Bolton, E. S.1914. Wax portraits and silhouettes. Boston: Massachusetts Society of the Colonial Dames of America.

Brown, W. H.1846. Portrait gallery of distinguished American citizens. Hartford, Conn.: E. B. and E. C. Kellogg.

Carrick, A. van L.1928. Shades of our ancestors. Boston: Little Brown and Co.

Cohn, M.1977. Wash and Gouache: A study of the development of watercolor. Cambridge, Mass.: Center for Conservation and Technical Studies, Fogg Art Museum.

Coke, D.1913. The art of the silhouette. London: Martin Seckler.

Coombs, E. I.1999. Personal communication. Cranston, R.I.

Coombs, E. I.2001. Casting light on some Edouart silhouette likenesses. In Dear print fan: A festschrift for Marjorie B. Cohn, ed. C.Bowen et al.Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Art Museums. 77–82.

Diehl, L. R.1938. Scissor silhouettes. Waterloo, Iowa: Rose Leaf Publishing Co.

Dorcy, SisterM. J.1944. A shady hobby. Milwaukee: Bruce Publishing Co.

Edouart, A. A. C. F.1835. A treatise on silhouette likenesses. London: Longman and Company.

Gettens, R., and G. L.Stout. 1966. Painting materials: A short encyclopedia. New York: Dover Publications

Hickman, P.1968. Silhouettes. New York: Walker and Co.

Hill, J.1984. New England itinerant portraitists. In Itinerancy in New England and New York, ed. P.Benes. Boston: Boston University and Dublin Seminar for New England Folklife Annual Proceedings. 150–71.

Hubard, J.1825. A catalogue of the subjects contained in the Hubard Gallery. 2d ed.New York: D. Fanshaw.

Jackson, E. N.1938. Silhouette: Notes and dictionary. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.

Krill, J.1997. Personal communication. September 12.

Laughon, H., and N.Laughon. 1984. A newly identified Edouart folio. Antiques126 (December): 1446–50.

Laughon, H., and N.Laughon. 1986. Shadow portraits of Washington. Antiques129 (February): 402–9.

Laughon, H., and N.Laughon. 1987. Auguste Edouart: A Quaker album. Richmond, Va.: Cheswick Press.

Laughon, N.1997. Personal communication, July 28.

Laughon, H., and N.Laughon. 1997. Personal communication. October 19.

Lee, J.1998. Book of heads. Illinois: Illinois Art Council and Illinois State University Research Grant.

Leslie, H.1939. Silhouettes and scissor-cutting. London: John Lane.

Lieber, F.1835. Encyclopedia Americana: A popular dictionary of arts, sciences, literature, history, politics, and biography. Philadelphia: Desilver, Thomas, and Co.

Linden, O.1998. Personal communication. Fiskars. October 15.

McSwiggan, K.1997. Silhouettes. Buckinghamshire, England: Shire Publications.

M�groz, R. L.1949. Profile art through the ages: A study of the use and significance of profile and silhouette from stone age to puppet films. New York: Philosophical Library.

Miles, E. G.1994. 1803: The year of the physiognotrace. In Painting and portrait making in the American Northeast, ed. P.Benes. Boston: Boston University and Dublin Seminar for New England Folklife Annual Proceedings. 118–37.

Miller, L. B., ed.1988. The selected papers of Charles Willson Peale and his family, vols. 1–2. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Miller, L. B.1997a. Personal communication. May 8.

Miller, L. B.1997b. Personal communication. July 7.

Nash, N.1810. The artist's assistant. Springfield, Mass.

National Portrait Gallery Curatorial File. National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C.

Norman, J.1814. The artists' companion, and manufacturer's guide, consisting of the most valuable secrets in arts and trades. Boston: E. G. House for J. Norman.

Oliver, A.1977. Auguste Edouart's silhouettes of eminent Americans, 1839–1844. Charlottesville, Va.: Published for the National Portrait Gallery, Smithsonian, by the University Press of Virginia.

Payne, J.1797. Instructions in the art of painting in miniature on ivory. London: R. Laurie and J. Whittle.

Peale's Museum. 1818. Peale's Museum, in the state house, Philadelphia. Broadside, Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University. April.

Piper, D.1970. Shades: An essay on English portrait silhouettes. New York: Chilmark Press.

Quimby, N. E.1953. Beauty in black and white: An artist with scissors. Richmond: Dietz Press.

Reese, W. n.d. Americana: 100 rare books, manuscripts and prints. Catalog no. 154. New Haven: William Reese and Company.

Rifken, B. J.1987. Silhouettes in America, 1790–1840: A collector's guide. Burlington, Vt.: Paradigm Press.

Roe, F. G.1970. Women in profile: A study in silhouette. London: John Baker, 1970.

Rosenblum, R.1957. The origin of painting: A problem in the iconography of romantic classicism. Art Bulletin39:279–90.

Rubi, C.1972. Cut paper, silhouettes, and stencils: An instruction book. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold Co.

Sellors, C. C.1948. The Peale silhouettes. American Collector17 (May): 6–8.

Simms, L. A.1937. The art of silhouette cutting. London: Frederick Warne and Co.

Smith, J.1995a. Conservation analytical laboratory characterization of three silhouettes from the Auguste Edouart album of eminent Americans. AIC poster presentation. American Institute for Conservation 23d Annual Meeting, St. Paul.

Smith, J.1995b. Technical analysis of black coatings on Auguste Edouart silhouettes. AIC preprints. American Institute for Conservation 23d Annual Meeting, St. Paul. Washington, D.C.: AIC. 107.

Swannell, M.1929. Paper silhouettes. London: George Philip and Son.

Townshend, B. A.1815–16. Introduction to the art of cutting groups of figures, flowers, birds, &c. in black paper. London: Printed for Edward Orme.

Townshend, B. A.1836. Sybil-leaves or drawing room scraps. London: Adolphus Richter and Co.

Valuable secrets concerning arts and trades; or, Approved directions from the best artists. 1795. Norwich, Conn.: T. Hubbard.

Vernay, A. S.1911. The silhouette. New York: Arthur S. Vernay Gallery.

Verplanck, A. A.1996. Facing Philadelphia: The social functions of silhouettes, miniatures, and daguerreo-types, 1760–1860. Ph.D. diss., College of William and Mary.

Ward, H.2001a. Personal communication. Whatman International. August 16.

Ward, H.2001b. Personal communication. Whatman International. August 24.

Wehlte, K.1967. The materials and techniques of painting. New York: Van Nostrand Reinhold Co.


An American heritage: American silhouettes. 1973. Hagerstown, Md.: Washington County Museum of Fine Arts.

Antiques. 1938. Profilist's progress. Antiques13(3):149–50.

Blattel, H.1992. International dictionary: Miniature painters, porcelain painters, silhouettists. Munich: Arts and Antiques Edition.

Brinton, A. C.1964. Quaker profiles, pictorial and biographical: 1750–1850. Lebanon, Pa.: Pendle Hill Publications.

Carrick, A. van L.1968. A history of American silhouettes: A collector's guide, 1790–1840. Rutland, Vt.: Charles E. Tuttle Co.

Columbian Museum. 1804. Columbian Museum, Milk-Street, Boston. Broadside, Beinecke Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Yale University.

The dictionary of art. 1996. New York: Macmillan Publishers. 28:713–14.

Dunlap, W.1834. History of the rise and progress of the arts of design in the United States. New York: G. P. Scott and Co.

Fouratt, M. E.1984. Ruth Henshaw Bascom, itinerant portraitist. In Itinerancy in New England and New York, ed. P.Benes. Boston: Boston University and Dublin Seminar for New England Folklife Annual Proceedings. 190–211.

Forgione, N.1999. “The shadow only”: Shadow and silhouette in late nineteenth-century Paris. Art Bulletin81:490–512.

Grant, J., and J.Fiske. 1887–89. Appleton's cyclopaedia of American biography. New York: D. Appleton and Co.

Groce, G. C., and D. H.Wallace. 1957. The New-York Historical Society's dictionary of artists in America, 1564–1860. New Haven: Yale University Press.

Guyton, W. L., and J. M.Koenig. 1980. A basic guide to identifying and evaluating American silhouettes. Waynesboro, Pa.: Renfrew Museum and Park.

Harrison, A. H.1916. The history of silhouettes and how to make them. St. Louis: Freelance Publicity and Syndicating Bureau of St. Louis.

Hickman, P.1975. Silhouettes: A living art. New York: St. Martin's Press.

Hickman, P.1980. The Andrews collection of silhouettes. Connoisseur295:237–41.

Jackson, E. N.1911. The history of silhouettes. London: The Connoisseur.

Johnson, A., ed.1961. Dictionary of American biography. New York: Scribner's.

Knittle, R. M.1937. Early Ohio taverns; tavern-sign, stage-coach, barge, banner chair and settee painters. Ashland, Ohio: Southworth-Anthoensen Press.

Lalibert�, N., and A.Mogelon. 1968. Silhouettes, shadows, and cut-outs. New York: Reinhold Book Corp.

Lister, R.1953. Silhouettes. An introduction to their history and to the art of cutting and painting them. London: Sir Isaac Pitman and Sons.

May, L. M.1938. A master of silhouette: John Miers, portrait artist, 1757–1821. London: Martin Secker.

Mayer, R.1969. A dictionary of terms and techniques. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell Co.

McCormack, H. G.1944. The Hubard Gallery duplicate book. Magazine Antiques45(February):68–69.

McCormack, H. G.1948. William James Hubard. Richmond, Va.: Valentine Museum.

McKechnie, S.1978. British silhouette artists and their work, 1760–1860. London: P. Wilson, for Sotheby Parke Bernet.

Muecke, F.1999. “Taught by love”: The origin of painting again. Art Bulletin81:297–302.

The Peale family: Creation of a family legacy, 1770–1870. Washington, D.C.: Corcoran Gallery of Art.

Rawson, M. N.1938. Candleday art. New York: E. P. Dutton and Co.

Romaine, L. B.1960. A guide to American trade catalogues. New York: R. R. Bowker.

Schmidt, G.1868. Mr. George Schmidt's method of teaching the art of psaligraphy: By self-instruction. Boston: L. Prang and Co.

Shaw, G. D.2001. In the shadow of the Peale family. Unpublished typescript. Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass.

Stemmler, J. K.1993. The physiognomical portraits of Johann Caspar Lavater. Art Bulletin75:151–68.

Swan, M. M.1931. A neglected aspect of Hubard. Magazine Antiques20:222–23.

Vernay, A. S.1913. American silhouettes by Auguste Edouart: A notable collection of portraits taken between 1839–1849. New York: Arthur S. Vernay Gallery.

Williamson, G. C.1904. The history of portrait miniatures. London: Bell.

Woodiwiss, J.1965. British silhouettes. London: Country Life.

Wright, R. L.1965. Hawkers and walkers in early America: Strolling peddlers, preachers, lawyers, doctors, players, and others, from the beginning to the Civil War. New York: F. Ungar Publishing Co.


TrueCore Card Stock for backing hollow-cuts, item 7670

Light Impressions P.O. Box 22708 Rochester, N.Y. 14692–2708


PENLEY KNIPE has a B.A. in anthropology from St. Lawrence University (1987) and an M.S. from Winterthur Museum/University of Delaware Program in Art Conservation (1997). She was an advanced-level intern at the Straus Center for Conservation and Technical Studies at the Harvard University Art Museums in 1997–98 and the Claire W. and Richard P. Morse Fellow in Paper Conservation at the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston in 1998–99. Since the fall of 1999 she has been an assistant conservator of works of art on paper in the Straus Center for Conservation and Technical Studies. Address: Straus Center for Conservation and Technical Studies, Harvard University Art Museums, 32 Quincy Street, Cambridge, Mass. 02138; e-mail: knipe@fas.harvard.edu.

Copyright � 2002 American Institution for Conservation of Historic & Artistic Works